PitHub
HomeExplore
New pit
MCP serverSave straight from your agent
About usHow it worksFAQBlogContact us
Sign in
PitHub
Sign in
HomeExploreCreateSign in

Explore

Loading…

Explore

Tagged #critique

ActiveNewMost usedRecommended
AllAI & Prompt Engineering324Engineering176Data & Analytics89Product4Design28Sales2Marketing4Finance
#critiqueClear filters
JOJonah Martin@jonahmartin·4w ago

The checklist I use for a prompt for honest product feedback

The useful bit was asking for trade-offs and a smallest test before committing to a full plan.

Jonah Martin

I am stuck on a prompt for honest product feedback. I need to review a product idea without defaulting to praise or inventing market evidence, but my current attempt is getting vague and too big. What would you check first?

Claudeclaude-opus-4.5

First, shrink the decision. Do not solve the whole subject at once. 1. Put the source of truth in the prompt. 2. Mark missing evidence instead of filling it in. 3. Add a stop condition before tool use. Write down the result you need by the end of this session. Then choose one input you trust and make a first pass that can be checked. If that pass fails, you will know which assumption to revisit instead of starting over.

Show all 3 messages
3412.4k
JOJonah Martin@jonahmartin·1mo ago

a prompt for honest product feedback: the version with actual constraints

This started as a messy question about a prompt for honest product feedback. The follow-up made the answer practical.

Jonah Martin

Give me a short checklist for a prompt for honest product feedback. I want something I can run before I call the work done.

Claudeclaude-opus-4.5

Use this pass: - [ ] The goal is one sentence and names the user or decision - [ ] Inputs are current, relevant, and traceable - [ ] Assumptions are visible - [ ] Put the source of truth in the prompt - [ ] Mark missing evidence instead of filling it in - [ ] Add a stop condition before tool use - [ ] One failure case has been tested - [ ] The next owner and next action are clear If you cannot check an item, mark it unknown. Do not quietly treat unknown as done.

Show all 3 messages
3311.2k
JOJonah Martin@jonahmartin·2mo ago

I asked Gemini for a second opinion on a prompt for honest product feedback

A compact prompt and the response it produced. Replace the bracketed parts with your own details.

Jonah Martin

Be blunt about my plan for a prompt for honest product feedback. I am going to collect everything, ask for a polished answer, and fix details later. What is likely to go wrong?

Geminigemini-2.5-pro

Three things. - “Everything” has no boundary, so weak inputs and strong inputs will be treated alike. - A polished answer can hide missing evidence. Ask for gaps and assumptions before prose. - “Fix details later” means there is no acceptance test now. A safer sequence is: define the decision, choose the minimum trusted inputs, make an ugly first pass, check it, then polish. For this task, mark missing evidence instead of filling it in.

Show all 3 messages
3312.7k
JOJonah Martin@jonahmartin·3mo ago

A smaller way to tackle a prompt for honest product feedback

Sharing the wording because it gave me something I could check instead of a confident wall of text.

Jonah Martin

For a prompt for honest product feedback, should I build a complete plan first or test one small slice? I have limited time and I do not want throwaway work.

ChatGPTgpt-5

Test one slice, but choose a slice that crosses the riskiest part of the problem. A tiny easy demo will only prove the easy part. Use this decision rule: - If reversing the choice is cheap, try it. - If the choice locks in data, money, or other people’s time, write the full decision first. - If uncertainty is concentrated in one step, test that step before planning around it. For a prompt for honest product feedback, make the first test produce evidence you can compare, not just something that looks complete.

Show all 3 messages
3414k
AYAya Lin@ayalin·2w ago

Forked from@jonahmartin/The a prompt for honest product feedback prompt I actually kept

The a prompt for honest product feedback prompt I actually kept

This started as a messy question about a prompt for honest product feedback. The follow-up made the answer practical.

Aya Lin

Help me review a product idea without defaulting to praise or inventing market evidence. Context: - Goal: [what a good result lets me do] - Current situation: [paste notes, draft, data, or constraints] - Audience: [who will use the result] - Deadline or limit: [time, budget, tools, length] Before answering, ask up to three questions only if the answers would materially change your recommendation.

ChatGPTgpt-5

This is usable as written. The important parts are the definition of done, the instruction to expose assumptions, and the request for a smallest test. For a prompt for honest product feedback, I would start with these checks: - Put the source of truth in the prompt - Mark missing evidence instead of filling it in - Add a stop condition before tool use If you share real material, remove anything private first and replace bracketed fields with concrete details.

Show all 3 messages
3200
KAKai Nolan@kainolan·2w ago

Forked from@jonahmartin/The checklist I use for a prompt for honest product feedback

The checklist I use for a prompt for honest product feedback

The useful bit was asking for trade-offs and a smallest test before committing to a full plan.

Kai Nolan

I am stuck on a prompt for honest product feedback. I need to review a product idea without defaulting to praise or inventing market evidence, but my current attempt is getting vague and too big. What would you check first?

Claudeclaude-opus-4.5

First, shrink the decision. Do not solve the whole subject at once. 1. Put the source of truth in the prompt. 2. Mark missing evidence instead of filling it in. 3. Add a stop condition before tool use. Write down the result you need by the end of this session. Then choose one input you trust and make a first pass that can be checked. If that pass fails, you will know which assumption to revisit instead of starting over.

Show all 3 messages
3200
OWOwen Morgan@owenmorgan·2w ago

Forked from@jonahmartin/I asked Gemini for a second opinion on a prompt for honest product feedback

I asked Gemini for a second opinion on a prompt for honest product feedback

A compact prompt and the response it produced. Replace the bracketed parts with your own details.

Owen Morgan

Be blunt about my plan for a prompt for honest product feedback. I am going to collect everything, ask for a polished answer, and fix details later. What is likely to go wrong?

Geminigemini-2.5-pro

Three things. - “Everything” has no boundary, so weak inputs and strong inputs will be treated alike. - A polished answer can hide missing evidence. Ask for gaps and assumptions before prose. - “Fix details later” means there is no acceptance test now. A safer sequence is: define the decision, choose the minimum trusted inputs, make an ugly first pass, check it, then polish. For this task, mark missing evidence instead of filling it in.

Show all 3 messages
3200
ASAsha Vega@ashavega·2w ago

Forked from@jonahmartin/A smaller way to tackle a prompt for honest product feedback

A smaller way to tackle a prompt for honest product feedback

Sharing the wording because it gave me something I could check instead of a confident wall of text.

Asha Vega

For a prompt for honest product feedback, should I build a complete plan first or test one small slice? I have limited time and I do not want throwaway work.

ChatGPTgpt-5

Test one slice, but choose a slice that crosses the riskiest part of the problem. A tiny easy demo will only prove the easy part. Use this decision rule: - If reversing the choice is cheap, try it. - If the choice locks in data, money, or other people’s time, write the full decision first. - If uncertainty is concentrated in one step, test that step before planning around it. For a prompt for honest product feedback, make the first test produce evidence you can compare, not just something that looks complete.

Show all 3 messages
3200
KAKai Hsu@kaihsu·2w ago

Forked from@jonahmartin/a prompt for honest product feedback: the version with actual constraints

a prompt for honest product feedback: the version with actual constraints

This started as a messy question about a prompt for honest product feedback. The follow-up made the answer practical.

Kai Hsu

Give me a short checklist for a prompt for honest product feedback. I want something I can run before I call the work done.

Claudeclaude-opus-4.5

Use this pass: - [ ] The goal is one sentence and names the user or decision - [ ] Inputs are current, relevant, and traceable - [ ] Assumptions are visible - [ ] Put the source of truth in the prompt - [ ] Mark missing evidence instead of filling it in - [ ] Add a stop condition before tool use - [ ] One failure case has been tested - [ ] The next owner and next action are clear If you cannot check an item, mark it unknown. Do not quietly treat unknown as done.

Show all 3 messages
3200
JOJonah Martin@jonahmartin·3mo ago

The a prompt for honest product feedback prompt I actually kept

This started as a messy question about a prompt for honest product feedback. The follow-up made the answer practical.

Jonah Martin

Help me review a product idea without defaulting to praise or inventing market evidence. Context: - Goal: [what a good result lets me do] - Current situation: [paste notes, draft, data, or constraints] - Audience: [who will use the result] - Deadline or limit: [time, budget, tools, length] Before answering, ask up to three questions only if the answers would materially change your recommendation.

ChatGPTgpt-5

This is usable as written. The important parts are the definition of done, the instruction to expose assumptions, and the request for a smallest test. For a prompt for honest product feedback, I would start with these checks: - Put the source of truth in the prompt - Mark missing evidence instead of filling it in - Add a stop condition before tool use If you share real material, remove anything private first and replace bracketed fields with concrete details.

Show all 3 messages
331987

Browse by tag

#ai314#chatgpt211#claude208#gemini208#prompting182#agents174#context-engineering172#coding160
24
Strategy31
Operations4
Customer Success3
People & Recruiting4
Security & Compliance8
Legal2
Other Professional1
#debugging106
#software-learning100
#data85
#analysis55
#statistics55
#202650
#data-literacy50
#prompt-template50
#trending-questions50
#business25
#design25
#testing25
#automation21
#finance21
#cash-flow16
#research16